Welcome to Teddy’s Brooklyn Style Pizza
Teddy’s Brooklyn Style Pizza brings a slice of New York to Middleburg, Virginia, offering a culinary experience steeped in tradition and flavor. Founded by Teddy, this charming locale captures the spirit of classic Brooklyn pizzerias, merging authentic recipes with a welcoming family atmosphere. With a menu that features the perfect balance of textures and flavors—from the crispy crust to rich cheese options—Teddy’s has become a beloved spot for pizza lovers. Patrons rave about the outstanding service and the inviting divey ambiance, making it ideal for families and gatherings. Here, every bite feels like a comforting embrace from home.
Teddy’s Brooklyn Style Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Really happy to have found this place! Moved about 7 months ago and had been looking for good pizza. Stumbled over Teddy's and stopped in. Not much seating so I took a couple slices to go, perfect crust and the perfect amount of grease. Loved it!
Heard a lot about this place, so had to try it. Well, let you tell it is worth the trip!!! The pizza was fresh, and awesome!! The service was great, Teddy the owner is fantastic!! The pizza shop reminds me of the ones your see on tv. Love it !!! Will come again !!!
Great pizza! Stromboli is fantastic too. Friendly staff, family atmosphere, quick service and reasonable prices.
Ammmmmmazing pizza. Best in the area by far, great service and prices. Definitely recommend
Best NY Pizza in NOVA.....Great service and price. Cant go wrong with Teddy's and nice quaint location.
After hearing so many positive things and reading the reviews on social media, as well as seeing Teddy's making the top 10 list in the Northern VA area I was finally able to give this small pizza joint in historic Middleburg a try on a weekday for lunch. Teddy is clearly passionate about the pies he makes and it's evident in watching and tasting his food. He's got the typical Italian "pizza joint" menu including pies subs, and other Italian entrée items. We opted for a white pizza, a cheese only pizza, and a pepperoni pizza and all three were INCREDIBLE!!! Easily the best pizza we've had in the area. The sauce was outstanding! The cheese was incredible!! The crust was perfect!!! But the way it all came together, the perfect amount of cook on the pizza and the flavors were OUTSTANDING! We truly understand why he's been getting the amazing reviews and recognition he's gotten and it' well-deserved! If you're in the mood for amazing NY style pizza, this is the place!
We got the cheese pizza. It was delicious. A large pizza was a great portion. The cheese and sauce were great. It was a true NY style. Take a bite and all the cheese comes off. We really enjoyed it. We also got the Philly cheesesteak super, also very good. A very large portion, and easily shareable. Great meat to topping ratio. Overall, a great spot in Middleburg. A few tables to sit and eat. But I think they do a lot of take out.
Location
-
9 E Federal St Middleburg, VA 20117 Hotline: (540) 687-8880
Welcome to Teddy’s Brooklyn Style Pizza, a charming gem nestled in Middleburg, VA. If you’re in search of the authentic taste of New York-style pizza, look no further. This delightful spot boasts a simple yet inviting atmosphere that echoes the vibrant pizza joints of Brooklyn.
Teddy's is not just about pizza; it offers a well-rounded menu with options for salads, desserts, and tantalizing calzones. Their classic cheese pizza, at just $10.95, can be customized to your liking, ensuring a personal touch to each pie. If you’re in the mood for something different, try the White Pizza, loaded with mozzarella, ricotta, fresh tomatoes, garlic, and basil for $18.95—a creamy delight that speaks volumes of its quality. And don’t overlook their side orders, including cheese fries that are a must-try!
- Location: 9 E Federal St, Middleburg, VA 20117
- Contact: (540) 687-8880
- Amenities: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor Seating, and Free Wi-Fi
What sets Teddy’s apart is not just the food, but the delightful community vibe. Reviewers rave about the welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and excellent service provided by Teddy himself. Chris G. mentioned how he found the perfect crust with just the right amount of grease, while Nick D. highlighted the fantastic stromboli and the quick service that makes dining here a pleasure.
Whether you’re dining with family, grabbing a bite on the go, or enjoying a casual evening out with friends, Teddy’s Brooklyn Style Pizza is a place where everyone feels at home. With reasonable prices and a lively environment, it’s perfect for groups or a cozy night with the family.
If you’re in the Middleburg area, don’t miss the opportunity to experience what the locals are buzzing about. Discover the delightful charm and delectable bites that make Teddy’s Brooklyn Style Pizza an absolute must-visit!
